Scrolling Minds: How Social Media Shapes Our Identities and Choices

Realistic photo of a man staring at his smartphone surrounded by floating social media icons, with “Inveigle Magazine” written at the top.
Scrolling and navigating between truth, misinformation, and influence.


More Than Just Scrolling

Every swipe, like, and share seems small, but together they form powerful patterns that influence how we see ourselves and others. Social media is no longer just a tool for entertainment—it has become a stage where identities are performed, relationships are negotiated, and entire communities are built. Social science reveals that these digital interactions don’t just influence what we think; they can actively help shape who we believe we are.


The Algorithm as a Mirror and a Guide

When we log into platforms like InstagramTikTok, or Facebook, algorithms tailor what we see based on past behavior. While this personalization feels convenient, it creates what sociologists call a “feedback loop of identity.”

  • A teen who “likes” fitness content may see more workout videos, which could inspire healthy habits—but also feed body image anxiety.
  • Someone who comments on political posts may be shown increasingly extreme content, reinforcing existing beliefs while closing off opposing views.

The algorithm acts like both a mirror (reflecting us back to ourselves) and a guide (subtly steering our choices). This creates what media theorists refer to as a “filter bubble,” where reality is curated rather than raw.

Composite image showing a man on stage with a trophy and a woman scrolling on her phone with social media icons
Everyday life is a stage—online and offline—where identity is constantly performed and judged.


Performing Identity Online

Sociologist Erving Goffman once compared everyday life to a stage where people perform roles to fit social expectations. Social media amplifies this phenomenon. Online, we carefully select photos, captions, and hashtags—building what psychologists call a “curated self.”

But this performance cuts both ways:

  • It allows individuals to highlight achievements and values, creating a sense of pride.
  • It also creates pressure to maintain a polished image, often at the expense of authenticity.

For younger generations, identity performance is almost inseparable from their digital footprint. What you post, who you follow, and how you interact online can define how others see you—and how you see yourself.

The Power and Pitfalls of the “Like” Economy

Psychologists compare likes and shares to micro-doses of social approval. Each notification releases dopamine, reinforcing the desire to post more. 

Over time, this “like economy” can shift motivations:

  • People begin curating content for validation rather than authentic expression.
  • Risk-taking behaviors may be rewarded with virality, encouraging stunts or extreme views.
  • Negative comments or a lack of engagement can spark anxiety, creating what researchers call “social media stress.”

In this way, technology capitalizes on deep psychological needs—particularly the need for acceptance and belonging.

Composite photo with four quadrants showing a fitness enthusiast, fashion influencer, gamer, and activist livestreaming, with social media icons
From fandoms to activism, digital tribes give people space to connect, experiment, and belong.

Belonging in Digital Communities

Social identity theory suggests we define ourselves through group memberships. Online, these groups might be fandoms, political movements, or lifestyle “tribes” (fitness enthusiasts, fashion lovers, gamers, activists). Unlike in-person communities, digital groups have fluid entry points—someone can join instantly, experiment with identity, and leave without consequence.

This flexibility is empowering, allowing people to connect across geography, race, or class. For marginalized voices, it creates spaces of solidarity and empowerment. 

But belonging comes at a cost: rapid exposure to group norms may pressure individuals to conform, even when those norms are harmful.

Comparison and Mental Health

While digital connections can be empowering, constant exposure to curated highlight reels often fuels comparison. Psychologists call this “upward social comparison”—the tendency to measure ourselves against those who appear more successful, beautiful, or happy.

  • Instagram vacations make our weekends look dull.
  • TikTok “glow-ups” can make personal progress feel inadequate.
  • LinkedIn achievements might make career paths seem behind schedule.

The paradox: while social media connects us, it also heightens feelings of loneliness and inadequacy. Studies link heavy social media use with increased rates of anxiety, depression, and body dissatisfaction—especially among young adults.

a man and women looking at smartphones surrounded by hashtags, fake news, political ads, and health posts
Scrolling through curated feeds means navigating between truth, misinformation, and influence.
  • Social Media and Decision-Making

    Beyond identity, social media also influences how we make decisions:

    • Consumer behavior: Influencers act as modern word-of-mouth marketers, subtly shaping purchasing choices.
    • Political views: Misinformation can spread faster than fact-checks, swaying elections and fueling polarization.
    • Health choices: Both harmful “miracle cures” and life-saving public health campaigns (like vaccine awareness) gain traction online.

    Behavioral economists point out that humans are “predictably irrational”—prone to making decisions based on emotion rather than reason. Social media exploits this tendency, embedding emotion-laden content into feeds to keep us engaged.

    Who Controls the Narrative?

    The rise of influencers, viral trends, and algorithm-driven news raises a critical question: 

    Who controls the narrative? While platforms appear user-driven, algorithms prioritize content that generates clicks, not necessarily truth or well-being. This creates a tension between corporate profit motives and public interest.

    • Sensational stories often trend over accurate reporting.
    • Outrage and controversy fuel more engagement than nuance.
    • “Echo chambers” make it harder for people to encounter differing perspectives.

    From a social science lens, this demonstrates the power dynamics of digital culture—where corporations act as modern gatekeepers of information, much like media networks of the past.

    Critical Thinking in the Digital Age

    Social scientists emphasize that the solution isn’t abandoning social media—it’s engaging with it critically. 

    Strategies include:

    1. Digital literacy: Recognize that what you see is curated, not neutral reality. Ask: Who benefits from me seeing this?
    2. Intentional use: Replace passive scrolling with purposeful engagement (e.g., following accounts that inspire growth).
    3. Boundary setting: Limit screen time, especially before sleep or during meals, to protect mental health.
    4. Offline balance: Strengthen face-to-face relationships, which research shows remain the most powerful predictor of happiness.

    Looking Ahead: The Future of Identity Online

    As artificial intelligence and augmented reality expand, social media may evolve into even more immersive experiences. Virtual influencers, AI-driven recommendations, and digital “metaverse” communities are reshaping what identity means in the 21st century.

    • Will future generations have multiple “selves”—offline, online, and virtual?
    • How will social scientists measure authenticity when identities are fluid across platforms?
    • What ethical boundaries should guide the design of algorithms that shape billions of lives?

    These questions remind us that social media is not just technology—it’s sociology in real time.

    Conclusion: Reclaiming the Scroll

    Social media is not inherently good or bad—it’s a tool that reflects and amplifies human behavior. The challenge lies in learning to use it without losing ourselves in the process. As social science reveals, our digital lives are deeply intertwined with our psychological and social realities. The more aware we become of these forces, the more we can scroll with purpose—shaping technology, instead of letting it silently shape us.


    Arica G
    Author: Arica G is the Founder and Editor of Inveigle Magazine. She created a premiere Lifestyle, Fashion, and Beauty Magazine to entice you towards positive change and increase the quality of life. Inveigle Magazine was born with Arica's love for writing and informing the Universe about various topics. 



    Inveigle Magazine

    Inveigle Magazine is a lifestyle, fashion, and beauty magazine. We love sharing informative articles with our readers. Follow us and stay up to date with the latest articles. facebook twitter pinterest

    Previous Post Next Post

    Advertisement